Skip to main content
追討易EASYDEBT
Renovation Disputes7 min

Major Repair Works Scaffolding Damaged Your Air-Con, Window, or Car? Claiming Against the Owners' Corporation

EasyDebt Editorial

EasyDebt Editorial

A cardboard-style illustration of a man on a Hong Kong residential balcony pointing at a cracked window pane, a window air-conditioner on the wall beside it, bamboo scaffolding and loose poles outside, and a green origami lion with dark-blue inner folds standing on four legs beside him.

If your building is due major repairs you will usually get a notice: scaffolding goes up on this date, air-conditioner brackets come off, windows are replaced, the external wall is renovated. You chose no contractor and signed nothing — yet once works begin, a window unit can come back with a buckled casing, a pane can crack, or the car parked below can be hit by paint, fragments or debris. This article deals with exactly that: your property was damaged by works the Owners' Corporation organised — who to claim from, what evidence to build and when, and how to escalate step by step.

To be clear on scope: if you hired your own renovator, see our contractor dispute guide; if concrete simply fell from the façade, see spalling concrete liability. This piece is about damage caused by the repair process itself.

Why Major Repair Damage Is Not Just a Contractor Problem

Most owners' first instinct is "the contractor broke it, so I claim from the contractor". But you have no contract with the contractor, and you may not even know which company runs which floor of scaffolding.

According to the Home Affairs Department, an Owners' Corporation is an independent legal entity established under the Building Management Ordinance. It has a legal responsibility to manage and maintain the common parts properly and must take all reasonably necessary steps to carry out the management duties in the deed of mutual covenant; it may also decide whether to hire a management company or other professional parties. Major repairs are decided, tendered and commissioned by the OC, so the natural first target for an affected owner is usually the OC.

Honestly, who ends up liable, and for how much, depends on the facts: whether the works really caused the damage, whether the OC took reasonable care, and whether you share responsibility (for example by not securing your unit after a notice). This is procedural information, not a promise of outcome.

Why These Disputes Are Increasingly Common

Major repair works are in the public eye: searches for 大維修 run at around 1,000 a month in Hong Kong and have risen sharply in recent months. Disputes between owners and OCs also make the news.

One public example: Eastweek reported in October 2024 that at a Sha Tin estate with works valued at about HK$390 million, the OC and its core members faced an expected 100-plus lawsuits, of which nearly 100 were filed by a group of owners at the Small Claims Tribunal alleging negligence and suspected inflation of costs, seeking the price difference.

Note that report is mainly about cost disputes, not a damaged air-con or car, and it records one side's allegations rather than findings. We cite it only to show that owners claiming money from an OC at the Small Claims Tribunal is a real and not unusual route.

Cardboard-style illustration: a repair worker in a yellow hard hat and hi-vis vest kneels on a balcony inspecting a window air-conditioner with a damaged casing, a blank clipboard on the floor, bamboo scaffolding in the background, and a green origami lion standing beside him.
Record damage the moment you find it: which item, where, when — and hand the photos to the management office.

The Owners' Corporation vs the Contractor

It helps to look at three relationships:

  1. You and the OC: the works are the OC's, so your damage claim normally goes to the OC. "We hired a contractor" does not by itself make the OC immune — the contractor was the OC's choice, acting under the OC's authority.
  2. The OC and the contractor: they have a contract. Whether the OC can recover from its contractor after compensating you depends on that contract; it is their matter, not yours.
  3. You and the contractor: you are not a party to that contract and generally cannot rely on it. Unless you can separately show the contractor was negligent towards you, in practice the claim usually goes to the OC.

Also, under section 28 of the Building Management Ordinance, an OC must take out and maintain third-party risks insurance for the common parts; according to Home Affairs Department material, since 1 January 2011 the minimum cover is HK$10 million per accident. So when you claim, ask in writing whether a policy exists and how to apply. Small, clear claims are often handled through insurance or directly. Whether a policy covers works-related damage depends on its terms, and we cannot say generally.

What to Do the Day You Find the Damage

The hardest part is rarely "who is responsible"; it is proving the works caused it. Once the scaffolding is down, everyone says "it may have been broken already". So:

  • Photograph the same day: the damage, its surroundings, any scaffolding or workers nearby, with dates. If you have earlier photos showing the item intact, keep them.
  • Keep the OC's notices: scaffolding dates, unit-removal arrangements and work schedules show the damage fell within the works period.
  • Complain in writing that day: email, letter or a logged entry at the management office, stating the item, when found, suspected cause and what you want done. Keep the receipt or reply. A spoken complaint proves little.
  • Get quotes: two independent repair or replacement quotes; for a car, the repair invoice.
  • Note witnesses: neighbours, security guards, management staff.

More on organising proof in our evidence preparation guide.

Typical OC Responses and Sizing the Claim

You will usually hear one of three lines. First: "It broke after the scaffolding came down, so it has nothing to do with the works." Your answer is the same-day photos, the circulated notice and the written complaint, which together place the damage inside the works period. Second: "The unit was old and already faulty." Here earlier photos, service records and the purchase receipt help show it worked normally before the works. Third: "We hired a contractor, so go to the contractor." As explained above, you have no contract with the contractor; do not be passed back and forth — ask the OC to reply in writing and keep the dates.

On amount, the repair cost is the usual starting point; replacement cost is considered when the item is not worth repairing. Depreciation of an older unit is a common point of argument, so keep the purchase year, model and receipt. A claim backed by specific quotes tends to be taken more seriously than a round number, which also gives the other side an excuse to delay.

If you reach a settlement with the OC, put the amount, payment date and what it settles in writing, and sign off only once the money has arrived, so the same issue is not reopened later.

If the works are still running, write again each time new damage appears rather than waiting for a single end-of-project letter: a dated trail of separate notices is far easier to connect to specific days on site, and it shows you raised each problem promptly instead of sitting on it. Keep one folder, on your phone and backed up, holding photos, notices, quotes and every reply in date order, so that you can hand the whole file to the OC, an insurer or the Tribunal without reconstructing events from memory.

Letter First, Tribunal Second

Step one: claim from the OC in writing. State the facts, the damage and the amount, and give a reasonable deadline (say 14 days). Our demand letter guide can help. For a small, well-evidenced claim an OC will often prefer to settle rather than invite more claims from other owners.

Step two: the Small Claims Tribunal. According to the Judiciary, the Tribunal hears property damage claims up to HK$75,000, and a claim may not be split to get under the cap. A window unit, a pane or a car repair usually falls inside that range; see our Small Claims Tribunal guide and claim form guide.

An OC usually acts through its management committee and a management company, so name the defendant correctly (typically "The Incorporated Owners of [Building Name]"); if unsure, ask the management office or the District Office first, or get help.

For a sense of how the Tribunal looks at a well-documented claim, see our case of a renovation balance recovered. The direction is reversed (a contractor recovering a balance), but the Tribunal looked at the same kind of material — signed documents, receipts and message records. It illustrates how evidence is read, not what will happen in your claim.

Cardboard-style illustration: a man crouches beside a parked car with a shattered windscreen, photographing the glass fragments on his phone, the licence plate a blank rectangle, a green origami lion standing on the bonnet, a Hong Kong residential tower and bamboo scaffolding behind.
A damaged car needs the same-day photos, a notice to the management office and a repair quote.

If you would like help organising evidence, sizing the claim and preparing the filing, see our repair dispute support or filing assistance service.

FAQ


EasyDebt is not a law firm. This article is general procedural information only and is not legal advice. Individual cases depend on Hong Kong law and tribunal decisions.

This article is for general reference only and does not constitute legal advice. We are not a law firm; please evaluate your individual case based on specific circumstances.